1 - 20 of 1,908 Bookmarks by Otter_reader
Navigation
List of Bookmarks
-
Tags
Summary
Info: A picture on a long lost phone leads to a revelation of just how far Heaven was once willing to go to keep the Winchesters on their course to the apocalypse. Set somewhere in Season 8 after Sam has begun the trials. Dean/Sam
- Language:
- English
- Words:
- 10,041
- Chapters:
- 1/1
- Collections:
- 1
- Comments:
- 20
- Kudos:
- 360
- Bookmarks:
- 119
- Hits:
- 6,263
Bookmarked by Otter_reader
10 Jul 2026
-
Tags
Summary
Jensen and Jared are texting and discussing how Jensen always brings him up, and Jared proposes something to Jensen.
-
Tags
Summary
Jensen's coworkers excitedly start up a hushed whisper when they pull their slips of paper, turning to each other and showing flashes of Jeff’s cramped handwriting. Jensen looks back down at his own.
Jared Padalecki.
Of course. Jensen's so fucked.
Or: Jensen--who isn't great at talking to people on the best of days--pulls Jared's name for the office Secret Santa. The problem? He's more than a little in love with him.
-
you make it hot in december by according2thelore for Jld71
Fandoms: Supernatural (TV 2005) RPF
18 Mar 2026
Tags
Summary
“Hi, welcome to Max’s! Would you like to try our Peppermint Snowman Mocha?”
Jensen jerks to attention, because that voice is way too close. Jensen is standing at the front of the line, glaring furiously at his phone. Someone behind him in line is already shifting on their feet in frustration.
Jensen blinks at the register, uncomprehending, and then looks up. And up. And up. And—
Holy shit.
There’s A Man behind the counter. Capital-A Capital-M.
Or: Jensen hates flavored coffee, but he really, really likes the barista that serves it. What is an awkward man to do?
-
Tags
Summary
Dean sighs. Three in the morning. He looks over at the other side of the bed, blinking the lights of the screen from his eyes, and sure enough, the other side of the bed is still made. Dean hauls himself back into a sitting position, and focuses on the leg of his dresser until the spinning stops.
Sam’s up there again.
Or: Dean comes up with a system to be alerted when Sam has bad nights after the Cage.
Written for WincestWednesdays July 2024 Event, Week 2: "Creative Solutions"!
Series
- Part 2 of WincestWednesdays July 2024 Event
- Language:
- English
- Words:
- 5,460
- Chapters:
- 1/1
- Collections:
- 2
- Comments:
- 18
- Kudos:
- 297
- Bookmarks:
- 58
- Hits:
- 3,157
Bookmarked by Otter_reader
06 Jul 2026
-
Tags
Summary
But that’s when he notices them: the rings.
The shining knickknacks on the table to Sam’s left aren’t just pieces of bargain-bin estate fluff. It’s jewelry. Now that Dean’s moved away, a shaft of light falls right onto the table, reflecting light directly into Sam’s vision. He blinks away the bright spots, and there they are. Sitting innocuously on the edge of the table closest to him.
Later, it will feel like fate. Right now, the feeling is inexplicable, as Sam’s burgeoning sentence dies on his tongue.
Or: After Chuck has been defeated and life is as good as it's ever been, Sam impulsively buys a pair of rings at an estate sale. Dean starts acting strangely.
Written for the Wincest 20th Anniversary Zine!
- Language:
- English
- Words:
- 12,384
- Chapters:
- 1/1
- Collections:
- 1
- Comments:
- 35
- Kudos:
- 580
- Bookmarks:
- 142
- Hits:
- 4,364
Bookmarked by Otter_reader
06 Jul 2026
-
Tags
Summary
There's a missing little girl in Louisiana. Sam loses himself trying to find her.
Bookmarked by Otter_reader
02 Jul 2026
-
Tags
Summary
Gabriel tells Sam, “Don't let anybody ever tell you you're just a pretty face,” and now Dean can’t stop thinking about it. He thinks about it during the day. He thinks about it at night. He even thinks about it in the middle of a case involving people getting strangled in locked rooms in front of their mirrors.
What are they trying to see in those mirrors? And, more importantly, what will Dean see in his mirror when he does the same thing?
Series
- Part 57 of Meta's Wincest Fics
-
Tags
Summary
It’s been 2 weeks since Dean and Dad left for a hunt.
Bookmarked by Otter_reader
28 Jun 2026
-
The Adventures of Dean Constantly Seeing Sam Getting Fucked by orphan_account
Fandoms: Supernatural
22 Feb 2016
Tags
Summary
Dean has walked in on Sam being fucked a couple of times before, but he never expected this.
Bookmarked by Otter_reader
28 Jun 2026
-
Tags
Summary
Sam has this irrational fear of hurting him, as if every time is the first one, and when he finally slicks up his cock and slides in, his eyes are latched on Dean's the whole time.
Bookmarked by Otter_reader
26 Jun 2026
-
Tags
Bookmarked by Otter_reader
26 Jun 2026
-
Tags
Summary
"Seriously, bro, you really that shy you can't look a girl in the eye while you're doing the dirty, or is there something else you wanna tell me?" Dean tilts his head, quirking one eyebrow the way he knows Sam finds infuriating, and is rewarded with a slam of the door and no clean laundry for a week.
Bookmarked by Otter_reader
26 Jun 2026
-
Tags
Summary
He just wanted to change some things - go back and redo the parts that lead to this. He didn't expect to end up here.
- Language:
- English
- Words:
- 49,834
- Chapters:
- 6/6
- Comments:
- 103
- Kudos:
- 1,011
- Bookmarks:
- 256
- Hits:
- 16,423
Bookmarked by Otter_reader
24 Jun 2026
-
Tags
Summary
Meta-comedy/drama set immediately post-4x18, The Monster at the End of This Book. Dean can't stop wondering why people would write gay porn about him and Sam. Research takes him to interesting places; re-reading novels for subtext, visiting message boards, and a really freaky place called LiveJournal. What he discovers is a sick fascination with fanfiction, more about gay sex than he ever wanted to know, and an even deeper obsession with understanding why people write this stuff. Meanwhile, they're hunting a mysterious monster that takes the form of a person's truest love to kill them slowly, the lines between fanfiction and reality are starting to break down, and they still have to stop Lilith and save the world.
- Language:
- English
- Words:
- 50,644
- Chapters:
- 8/8
- Comments:
- 342
- Kudos:
- 3,152
- Bookmarks:
- 934
- Hits:
- 75,986
Bookmarked by Otter_reader
17 Jun 2026
-
Tags
Summary
It was just a stupid bet. Something to make Sam look silly. Dean didn't expect Sam to actually see it through. He definitely didn’t think he’d be caught out over his less-than-brotherly feelings for Sam.
Then Sam showed up in that tight red dress… and the rest is history.
- Language:
- English
- Words:
- 7,070
- Chapters:
- 1/1
- Collections:
- 1
- Comments:
- 14
- Kudos:
- 202
- Bookmarks:
- 42
- Hits:
- 2,615
Bookmarked by Otter_reader
12 Jun 2026
-
Tags
Summary
"It was great not thinking about our stupid thing for ten whole minutes," Dean said. "How many ten-minute intervals are there between now and when we die?"
Sam was looking at his mouth, and now that he knew to look for it, he wondered how often he'd missed it before.
"Depends on how soon I can put a bullet in my brain," Sam croaked.
Bookmarked by Otter_reader
09 Jun 2026
-
Tags
Summary
Jensen carries the beanie Jared gifted him, wherever he travels. He pulls it down over his eyes and sleeps like a baby... until the magic runs out. He can't sleep and now his only hope is that Jared can somehow fix the beanie again.
Bookmarked by Otter_reader
07 Jun 2026
-
Tags
Summary
Sam’s scariest trait is his puppy dog eyes and Dean knows his baby brother has him wrapped around his finger.
Typical weecest smut I know thousands of people write better, but I couldn’t stop my hands, I’m sorry.
Bookmarked by Otter_reader
07 Jun 2026
-
You Are the Center of Our Little World by Bitter Honey (taiyou_nii_chan), taiyou_nii_chan
Fandoms: Supernatural
23 Mar 2022
Tags
Summary
Despite Sam having no idea about it, he is the center of both his dad and his big brother's world, and he can rock both of them with just the movement of his little finger.
A little bit of John/Sam and Dean/Sam mixed into a soft but weird love triangle with a spark of struggles with unrequitted feelings.
Bookmarked by Otter_reader
07 Jun 2026